What makes Keenan Reynolds a great option quarterback?
Quarterbacking the flexbone offense is not an easy thing to do and former Navy head coach and current Georgia Tech head coach Paul Johnson came up with a list of qualities that determine whether or not a prospect can lead an option offense.
Let's take a look at what makes current Navy QB Keenan Reynolds the perfect signal-caller for the Mids' flexbone offense:
1. Does the prospect have the willingness to get off the ground after a "big hit", call the same play and run it aggressively?
If the answer is "yes" he has the mental and physical toughness to be an option quarterback. Mental and physical toughness is the quarterback's ability to remain poised, confident, determined, and courageous regardless of what happens on the field -- or off the field for that matter. Mental and physical toughness, not sheer athletic ability, is the key ingredient in a winning QB. A quarterback who has average athletic ability but high mental and physical toughness is more likely to win than one with excellent athletic ability and marginal toughness.
When Ohio State linebacker Joshua Perry talked to the media, he had this to say about Reynolds, "He's their guy," Perry said. "He's a guy who isn't necessarily a burner, speed-wise, but he has really good vision and he knows where the seams are. Once he puts his foot on the ground and he gets vertical, that's what he likes to do. We have to take really good angles. We can't overrun anything."
Reynolds mental and physical toughness was shown last season in Navy's 41-35 victory over Indiana. Navy faced a 4th-and-1 at the Indiana 49 yard line with roughly two minutes remaining in the game. Navy coach Ken Niumatalolo had a decision to make: would he go for it with the chance to ice the game, or punt the ball and give his defense a chance to save the game? He decided to put the ball in Reynold's hands and it paid off -- but barely.
They called their bread-and-butter play: Reynolds faked the hand-off to the "B" back (fullback) and had nowhere to go with the Indiana defense playing it perfectly. Reynolds was hit in the backfield but lunged forward for the down to clinch the win for the Midshipmen:
2. Does the quarterback have enough athletic ability (speed, quickness and balance) to run for a first down on 3rd-and-7 when the defense forces the quarterback to carry the ball on an option play?
In 2013, Reynolds rushed for 1,346 yards and a whopping 31 touchdowns, including an NCAA record breaking seven touchdown game versus San Jose State. When looking at his 2013 situational statistics, Reynolds was forced to carry the ball on 3rd-and-7 through 3rd-and-9 six times, where he averaged seven yards per carry and converted the first down twice. On 3rd-and-10 or longer, he was forced to carry the ball seven times and he also converted the first down twice. On fourth down, Reynolds carried the ball 11 times and converted the first down a staggering eight times.
Also, Reynolds' toughness really shows as games wear on, as he scored 22 out of his 31 rushing touchdowns in the second half of games. He also rushed for 20+ yards 12 times in the second half compared to only three times in first halves. It is safe to say that Reynolds has the athletic ability to convert first downs and make big plays when they matter the most.
3. Does the prospect have the willingness to execute option plays, not just tolerate running the option?
When it comes to execution, his statistics speak for themselves. But here's visual proof:
So how does the triple option work?
Navy runs the 'flexbone' offense, which is a run-first attack that has produced some of the best single season rushing yardage marks in NCAA history. The staple of the flexbone is the inside veer, a triple option.
Here is the Navy flexbone offense pre-snap:
As shown above, the "B" back is lined up behind the quarterback, while the two "A" backs are the players on the wings.
The diagram below shows the inside veer (triple option) versus a 4-3 defense:
The quarterback needs to "count" defenders in the option game, as to which defenders to read to make the correct decision in the triple option.
#1 defender is the first defensive lineman on or outside the playside tackle (circle).
#2 defender is the first defender stacked or outside the #1 defender (square).
The Navy playbook includes their rules when running the triple option:
(BS= back-side, PS= playside)
The triple option begins with the back-side "A" back going in tail motion. The quarterback can either hand the ball off on a dive up the middle to the "B" back, take it around end himself based on the defensive end, or begin to take it and pitch it to the motioning "A" back.
This is where having a smart and talented quarterback like Reynolds helps tremendously because of how easily he can read a defense. He helps out the offensive line by reading the correct defenders in a split-second and taking them out of the play, which allows the offensive line and any other blocker to double-team other defenders. That is what makes a Reynolds' led offense precisely so dangerous.